Charting Gold

by | Jun 21, 2010 | Howard Katz | 2 comments

Do you LOVE America?


    Each commodity and each economic good has its own characteristics, and before you trade any market seriously, you should stick your toe in the water, so to speak, (meaning to trade at a level you can afford). In this way, you can acquire knowledge of the characteristics of the particular market.


    I do not recommend paper trading because any market has a way of grabbing hold of your emotions and making you do things which you would not do under the perfect conditions of an academic study (where there is no money at stake and no time pressure). Most people in the markets are acting on their emotions, and if you want to take their money, then you must be in control of yours. And the best way to learn to do that is to trade with your own money (but always an amount you can afford to lose).

    Indeed, this experience in controlling your own emotions is so important that it applies to those around you (who are supposed to be on your side). Very often a giant emotion will dominate a market. This emotion becomes so strong and so universal that it is very hard to take a position against it. But when I had gotten to the point where I had mastered this, I found that there was another trap. I kept running into a series of mistakes on the part of the people around me because they had succumbed to the prevailing emotion and were not properly executing my orders.

    Of the various technical theories on the markets, my criteria for deciding which ones to use is based on what works. And I have found the best results with the chart patterns described in Technical Analysis of Stock Trends by Edwards and Magee. These are simple, geometric patterns with forecasting implications. When one of them appears, it is usually reliable but not perfectly. (Edwards and Magee say they work 70% of the time.) For this reason, I try to increase my probability of success by finding 2 corresponding patterns in goods known to move together.

    For example, consider the ascending triangle which formed in gold from March ’08 to October ’09 and broke out thereafter. Let us give this a 70% chance of hitting its price objective line (which is the line drawn parallel to the bottom line of the triangle and going through the upper left hand point). The price objective line is rising very rapidly. If gold hits it next spring, it will be at $3,300. If it hits it in spring 2012, then the price will be between $4,500 and $5,000. Since this number is very high, it has the quality of too-good-to-be-believed.

    However, we are now getting another ascending triangle in the HUI. The only difference is that the triangle in gold broke out last October while the triangle in the HUI looks ready to break out in a matter of weeks. If it does, then we can compound probabilities as follows. The probability of failure in gold is 30%. The probability of failure in the HUI will also be 30%. It is like the math problem of flipping a coin twice and asking what is the chance that you will lose both times.

    Our chance of losing both times in the markets is (1 – .70) x (1 – .70) = .30 x .30 = .09. Thus our chances of being wrong are only 9% instead of 30%. If we can find another good chart pattern in a related good (say, silver), we could multiply our probability even more. If silver breaks out of a corresponding triangle, then we have .30 x .30 x .30 = 2.7%. That is, our chances of being wrong will be less than 3%. And those are good odds to play.

    All bullish chart formations must be confirmed by increased volume on the breakout. Bearish formations do not need volume confirmation. (Stocks need volume to rise, but they fall of their own weight.)

    Almost all chart patterns have price objectives attached to them. This tells you how far, at a minimum, the economic good will travel before reversing. For a triangle, the price objective is not a point (as it is in most cases) but a line. Before the chart reverses, it will reach the price objective line. This means that the slower the chart moves the higher it will go.

    Below we have a symmetrical triangle which formed over the middle part of 2009 and broke out in September. Notice how gold reached the price objective line of this triangle in November, and this was an important clue for my call of an intermediate reaction in gold in early December. A price objective or price objective line is always a minimum. This means that the good has to at least reach this point. When it does, there is usually an intermediate (or short term) reaction. And then the good may continue up to a higher level.


    Above we have a head and shoulders bottom in gold extending from December ’09 to late April ’10. Its name comes from its shape, which is that of a man’s head and shoulders turned upside down. (There is also a head and shoulders top, which is rightside up). The line joining the two high points is the neckline, and the formation is complete when prices break above the neckline (a little above $1,160, in late April). Notice that the $80 price break in gold of mid-May was a very nice return to this neckline (which has now become support).

    To get the price objective on a head and shoulders bottom, we measure the distance from the bottom of the head to the neckline (on a semi-log chart). The distance from the bottom of the head to the neckline is 10%. Projecting a 10% rise from $1,162. We then measure upward from the neckline at the point where the price action crosses above it (also $1,162). This gives us an objective of $1,281. If we use the electronic gold chart, which records trading overnight, the calculation is close to $1,300. So this objective has not yet been reached.

    Gold is a good chart commodity. It forms chart patterns frequently, and they are reliable. I mean to show by this study that good technical analysis is not too difficult for the average person. Quality (recognizing the patterns and applying them correctly) is more important than quantity (knowing a large number of patters) for the reason that a few, simple patterns tend to repeat. You must take some risks in trading, but if you stick out your neck too far, you will eventually get it chopped off. So limit possible (worst case) losses to 3-6 months of income or 20% of capital.

    As a teaser, I will leave you with a final chart pattern, which completed on Friday. Try to identify it and see if you can calculate its price objective. (Hint, you will need to print out the computer image on paper and complete work with pencil and ruler.)


    If you are interested in my approach to gold, then I invite you to subscribe to the One-handed Economist, my fortnightly financial letter, which follows the markets and makes recommendations for maximum profit with safety. OHE is written every other Friday with special bulletins when something important occurs. For regular mail customers, It is mailed on Saturday/Sunday. For e-mail customers, the letter is posted on my website, (password protected). Also included is my model conservative portfolio which, at the present time consists of three gold stocks and two gold futures contracts. The model portfolio started at the beginning of the century at $100,000 and just this week reached the $200,000 mark. Meanwhile, the average US general equity fund is flat for the same period. I have been bullish on gold since December 2002 and have been an active gold bug since 2005. You can subscribe by visiting my web site, and clicking the Pay Pal button. Or you can subscribe by sending a check for $290 through the U.S. mail ($10 cash discount) to: The One-handed Economist, 614 Nashua St. #122, Milford, N.H. 03055. Thank you for your interest.

    # # #


    It Took 22 Years to Get to This Point

    Gold has been the right asset with which to save your funds in this millennium that began 23 years ago.

    Free Exclusive Report
    The inevitable Breakout – The two w’s

      Related Articles


      Join the conversation!

      It’s 100% free and your personal information will never be sold or shared online.


      1. Gold is waaay overbought in the near-term.  Wait for a pull-back near the 1,000 -1050 range before going back in.  Or just make it easy for yourself and just buy silver since its at depressed levels still.

      2. Buy a next strike put and a next strike call.
        Then you don’t have to worry about which way it’s going.

      Commenting Policy:

      Some comments on this web site are automatically moderated through our Spam protection systems. Please be patient if your comment isn’t immediately available. We’re not trying to censor you, the system just wants to make sure you’re not a robot posting random spam.

      This website thrives because of its community. While we support lively debates and understand that people get excited, frustrated or angry at times, we ask that the conversation remain civil. Racism, to include any religious affiliation, will not be tolerated on this site, including the disparagement of people in the comments section.