Profit In Silver

by | Nov 1, 2010 | Howard Katz | 11 comments

Do you LOVE America?



    Above we see the last two month’s price action for silver. I recommended that subscribers switch from gold contracts (on the Comex) to silver contracts on Sept. 17. Since that time, silver is up 18%. Over the same period, gold advanced by 6%.


    What is going on here? Evidently some of the precious metals are more precious than others. Let us look at the charts of gold (above) and silver (below) over the past 2½ years.


    Starting from the March 2008 high to Friday’s close gold advanced 29%. Starting from the same point to Friday’s close silver advanced 12%. If we end the period at Labor Day, then gold is up almost 25%, and silver is flat.

    There is a general sense among gold bugs that gold and silver move together. This is true in the very long term, but it is perhaps more accurate to say that they take turns. When the mood of the precious metals community is conservative, they favor gold, and gold outperforms silver. But when the mood becomes more speculative, they favor silver, and it outperforms gold.

    Because of the 25% move in gold from March ’08 to Labor Day ’10, then silver has become undervalued. After Labor Day, silver began to move aggressively indicating that it was beginning to correct its undervaluation and move to a more traditional relationship to gold.

    It is well known that silver is more volatile than gold. You can make more, but you can lose more. The key is to know when silver is playing possum and when it is waking up.

    I express this relationship by saying that silver is gold’s little brother. First the big brother moves ahead, and the little brother lags behind. But then the little brother says, “Wait for me,” and runs to catch up.

    For example, from mid-1970 to year-end 1974 gold made a steady advance (from $35/oz. to just under $200/oz.). Instead of silver tracking this move it went sideways until the end of 1973 and then exploded (from $2/oz. to almost $6½/oz.) by early 1974. Silver’s move up was much more rapid and occupied a much shorter period of time.

    From mid-1976 to January 1980, gold moved up from slightly above $100/oz. to $875/oz., again in a gradual pattern. Silver, however, moved sideways until 1978 when it began its incredible move, known as the Hunt silver bubble, from $5/oz. to over $50/oz. Bunker Hunt tried to corner the world’s supply of silver and wound up virtually broke. He learned the economic lesson that one cannot manipulate a free market.

    This gives us a good picture of the character of silver. Silver is the volatile precious metal. It spends much less time going up than gold, but it goes up much more rapidly. As noted above, we have recently spent a 2½ year period during which gold has been up nicely while silver has been essentially flat. Then around Labor Day silver broke out from a giant (almost) ascending triangle and from a smaller (exactly) ascending triangle. I spotted these two technical signals as telling us that silver was ready to move.

    It is true that silver can be dangerous, but if you also follow gold and keep in mind that the two goods move in sympathy with each other, this gives you a check and balance. Gold is not dangerous. It moves conservatively and moderately, and it obeys the technical signals very nicely. When a move in silver is confirmed by a technical signal in gold, this gives added confidence.

    Furthermore, the safest thing about the financial markets is profits under the belt. There is nothing which quite protects you so well as a profit that you have just made because now you can make a big whopper of a mistake and still come out with no net loss. Therefore, while safety must always be kept in mind, one must not be afraid to take a reasonable risk in pursuit of a good profit. This is an area where the technicals are very helpful. For example, take the recent breakout in silver above $21. Using the 3 rd chart above, the people who believe in the fallacy of the fair price have assumed that the fair price for silver was between $9 and $21. Now that $21 has been penetrated, their assumption shifts, and the “fair” price becomes $21. Therefore, if silver returns to $20-21, then these people will come in to buy. They represent support for us.

    Thus the buy signal for silver issued by the One-handed Economist on Sept. 17 was protected as soon as silver broke above $21. This tactic of buying a little above support is very valuable for two reasons. First, it sharply decreases the chances that the good will go down. Second, in the worst case it gives you a point where you know to cut your losses short. Thus you increase your chance of a profit and cut your losses short.

    At the present time, many of the precious metal indexes are showing giant ascending triangles complete with breakouts. And of course, we have just heard Ben Bernanke say that he is; about to make another massive increase in the U.S. money supply over the next 6 months (bringing the total U.S. money supply since mid-2008 up to approximately a triple). This is the economic fundamental which gold and silver and other commodities are forecasting by racing for the moon.


    Above is a chart comparing my performance (in the One-handed Economist’s Model Conservative Portfolio) with U.S. Diversified Equity Funds (representing what an investor would have today if he had started with $100,000 at the beginning of the century). Equity Funds is $113,000. Katz’s Model Conservative Portfolio is $251,000. As you can see, if you had put your money with me, it would now have multiplied by 2½ times.

    Furthermore, the big sell-off in late 2008 cost most people quite a bit of money. Regular readers of the One-handed Economist know that this was the fake-out move whereby the paper aristocracy creates a fictitious “deflation” in the public mind precisely to gather political support for a policy of “inflation” (of which QE2 is the latest aspect). It is the “inflation which is the real policy and lasts the longest time, and if you get caught by the fictitious “deflation,” you have to hang tough and wait for things to go the other way. This past month we completed most of the recovery from the late 2008 decline, and we are now in good position to leave the rest of the field in the dust.

    If you want to join us and leave the field in the dust, then you may subscribe to the One-handed Economist by going to my web site,, and pushing the Pay Pal button ($300). Or you may send $290 ($10 cash discount) to: The One-handed Economist, 614 Nashua St. #122, Milford, N.H. 03055

    Thank you for your interest.


    It Took 22 Years to Get to This Point

    Gold has been the right asset with which to save your funds in this millennium that began 23 years ago.

    Free Exclusive Report
    The inevitable Breakout – The two w’s

      Related Articles


      Join the conversation!

      It’s 100% free and your personal information will never be sold or shared online.


      1. More like….Survive with Silver!

      2. Me likey the silver…

        I’ve always thought that silver was prettier to look at than gold & I love that it’s much more affordable…:)

      3. i’d much rather have a neat stack of crisp new united states federal reserve ten dollar bills backed by the full faith and credit of the american government than any junk silver coins.

        my girl friend told me my 1964 kennedy half dollar is worth $8.60. i went to the grocery store and guess what -they wouldn’t give me groceries more than fifty cents for this piece of junk silver coin.

        all this gold and silver palaver is nonsense. the ten dollar bill is real money -anywhere! ! ! !

      4. Marc Faber is predicting a crackup boom in silver prices soon. He believes it will hit $30 in the next few months possilby!

      5. More like 50 next year with Asians taking poss of physical only.  I’m thinking 30 before X-mas.

      6. Shroomer…
        Love the supermarket story! Keep ’em comin! And I’ll gladly trade you my Lincoln FRN for your 1964 Kennedy any time. Just think! $5.00 in groceries for just $0.50 cents. You’d be a fool to pass up this offer.

      7. People like Ted butler and David Morgan  speak very highly of silver.David morgan said yesterday taht he believes at some point intime, that silver will be briefly the same price as Gold is. When physical shortages occur and the shorting of the silver occurs  and the lack of production all contribute to a once in alifetime scenerio .It is possible that silver could be the same as the price of gold , but it will be only a little while , and only those that have physical  silver  will benefit because by that time getting physical silver will be impossable. Right now since silver is a small market, If the people who kabe slv(paper silver in the market) asked for physical , It would destroy comex and cause the boom to to the moon . In all honestly,I see silver to 50 bucks in 3 years or less.But the wild card is if a WaR happens or some other changeing events , this timeline can be a lot shorter .silver will go into phases, first 25, then 50 , then 75 and finally 1000 bucks an oz, once it hits 1000 bucks an oz, then anything can happena dnt he prices of precious metals will swing wildly  and it will be impressive !  Hi Ho silver  !!!!!!!!

      8. Agreed Shaef but not thinking in $.

      9. If you want to read a book which will enlighten you about the creation of the Federal Reserve System as well as the history of central banking in America you should read:
        G. Edward Griffin’s The Creature From Jekyll Island

        Chairman Bernanke is destroying our currency by buying US Treasury Bonds with newly created paper Federal Reserve Notes. SInce the Fed was created in 1913 the purchasing power of the dollar has dropped over 95%.

        you ought to get out of paper FDRs into gold or silver or mining shares.

        The reason we are not seeing much inflation despite all the printing is that most of the new money is sitting in bank vaults because few are willing to borrow given the uncertainties regarding taxes and costs of new employees.

        Read Atlas Shrugged and join us at where you can continue to learn and educate yourself about economics and politics.

      Commenting Policy:

      Some comments on this web site are automatically moderated through our Spam protection systems. Please be patient if your comment isn’t immediately available. We’re not trying to censor you, the system just wants to make sure you’re not a robot posting random spam.

      This website thrives because of its community. While we support lively debates and understand that people get excited, frustrated or angry at times, we ask that the conversation remain civil. Racism, to include any religious affiliation, will not be tolerated on this site, including the disparagement of people in the comments section.